There’s Nothing Educational About Educational Toys

This post may include affiliate links and I may earn commission if you make a purchase through these links.

Which toy is better – a computer, or a box? A box – of course! Surprised? You shouldn’t be! A computer obviously has merit and value – think of the capabilities! But….a box does, too. Consider how often a toddler receives a gift, only to play with the box instead. It’s time to face the facts: there’s nothing educational about educational toys.

‘Educational Toys’: All About Marketing

The educational toy industry has always been profitable, and remains so. Friends and relatives alike often express love and affection through gifts. These well-meaning folks might prefer buying an ‘educational’ toy for the child versus something not labeled as such.

Their intentions are pure and perhaps they don’t know the first thing about toys – so they make their decision based on the word ‘educational’ on the box. Truth be told, the word ‘educational’ on a toy has about as much meaning as the word ‘healthy’ on a blueberry muffin. At best, ‘educational’ is subjective – at worst, misleading. Unfortunately, there’s nothing educational about educational toys.

What Are Educational Toys, Anyway?

If you’re a regular reader of this blog, you already know that it focuses on open-ended toys, purposeful play and child-led learning. ‘Educational’ toys do not figure into the equation. At the same time, though, every toy is educational – but what is it teaching?

Is it simply a matter of semantics? Perhaps. What does ‘educational’ really mean? The popular definition of an educational toy is one that ‘develops a special skill or is about a particular subject’. Manufacturers who market these toys will espouse their intrinsic value of helping children advance cognitively – but this claim is unproven. There’s nothing educational about educational toys.

What’s the Point of Play?

Is it the act of play itself that helps children to learn and grow, or is it a particular toy? It’s mostly about play itself, but obviously the object has some influence. The act of playing is so important to the overall development of a child that it has been recognized by the United Nations High Commission for Human Rights as a right for every child.

Maria Montessori said, “Play is the work of the child.” When children play, they learn and grow in every way imaginable, improving small and gross motor skills, developing language strategies, growing their imaginations and generally making connections with the world around them.

This is how children learn – by actively engaging with everything in their environments. Play is essential to the cognitive, physical, social and emotional growth of the child. There is no ONE TOY that will cause a child to grow cognitively. Instead, it is the synergistic aspect of everything that converges during playtime.

The Evolution of Toys

Children have always found ways to entertain themselves, even if ‘formal’ toys were not involved. Beginning with rocks and sticks, children interacted with their environment and learned while doing so.

Fast forward to 1693, when philosopher John Locke’s Locke’s Blocks came on the scene, with the intention of making learning to read more enjoyable. These blocks included letters, and were the precursors to primary-colored ABC blocks.

The next step in educational toys came between 1836 and 1850, when Friedrich Froebel, founder of Kindergarten, developed ‘Froebel’s Gifts‘. These specially-shaped geometric wooden figures supported learning about number, size, shape, weight, and cause and effect. 

Another famous early childhood icon, Italian researcher Maria Montessori, is responsible for the next milestone in educational toys, which included multicolored rods, cylinders, towers and more. Montessori published the English version of her book The Montessori Method in 1912, which described the structure and function of these items.

Were Froebel’s and Montessori’s toys considered ‘educational’ in their day? If not ‘educational’, definitely ‘clinical’. While we know how much children learned by manipulating these items, the average home didn’t contain either Montessori’s nor Froebel’s playthings. Instead, most children at this time had yoyo’s, dolls and pogo sticks for toys.

How Did Educational Toys Come to Be?

Our level of concern about children definitely lives on a continuum. Let’s just say that there weren’t many ‘helicopter parents’ in the 1700’s.

As the Industrial Revolution dawned in the late 1700’s/early 1800’s, more people were working (read: more poor people were working). They needed somewhere safe to leave their children while they went to their factory jobs. For this purpose, ‘Infant schools’ were offered in churches, factories, and even private homes.

Wisconsin led the way in 1873, when they developed the first preschool. Other states followed Wisconsin, offering many versions of early childhood education, including nursery schools, day care centers and preschools.

About fifty years later, the NAEYC (National Association for the Education of Young Children) was established. Their mission is to promote high-quality early learning for all children, birth through age eight, by connecting practice, policy and research.

As child care facilities grew in popularity and advocacy organizations (NAEYC, etc.) became prevalent, there was more focus on child development. As a result, like a Judy Clock, the educational toy market began ramping up considerably.

Choosing Toys

When asked for toy recommendations, play experts today would not say ‘buy the educational ones’, but would advise ‘the simpler, the better’. Toys have gotten much more sophisticated since the late 1600’s, though, and finding simple playthings today is a bit of a challenge.

Some of the top toy companies currently include LEGO, Fisher Price, Mattel, Barbie, and Hasbro. Interestingly, LEGO, which began manufacturing its signature plastic bricks in the 1950’s, offers the most open-ended toys. LEGOs can be used to build virtually anything – the only limit is your imagination.

Do these top companies manufacture some open-ended toys? Sure they do – but one has to look a little harder.

Personally, I prefer to shop small. 

Check out Monti Kids. A subscription that provides a personalized box of Montessori toys designed by Montessori teachers based on your child’s age and stage of development. 

Or shop at one of my favorite online toy stores! 

Check out The Natural Baby Company or Maple + Lark

Summary

A box labeled ‘educational’ is nothing more than a marketing ploy. Don’t be fooled. A durable, open-ended, multi-purpose toy will keep up with the busiest child long after the box is gone!

If you want more individualized help you can set up a free 15 minute consultation to chat about your play space design needs.

Interested in getting your little one to play independently?

Check out my Purposeful Playspace e-course to learn how to create a space for your children that invites them to playin ways that are more engaging, purposeful and independent.

Want more information about how play impacts your child’s development?

Check out my e-book: Simply Play: Everything You Need To Know About The Most Important Part of Childhood

Love this post? Check out some of the articles below.

What are the stages of play? Jean Piaget’s Theory of Play!

This post may include affiliate links and I may earn commission if you make a purchase through these links. How can a theory published in 1936 still help you to understand your children and how to encourage them through their cognitive development?  While Jean Piaget’s Theory of Play is closing in on its hundred-year anniversary…

What are the ages and stages of child development? (Bonus chart!)

Get the ages and stages development chart here!! This post may include affiliate links and I may earn commission if you make a purchase through these links. During the first 3 years of life babies and toddlers are making 1-2 million neural connections a minute.  Mind blown! During those years they go through massive growth…

Are Pikler triangles worth it? abso-freakin-lutely

Are Pikler triangles worth it? abso-freakin-lutely This post may include affiliate links and I may earn commission if you make a purchase through these links. So what is this magic triangle that seems to be in every playroom on Instagram?  It’s a Pikler triangle and there are some great reasons why so many moms are…

Episode 5: The Psychological Importance of Play + How to Recover from Helicopter Parenting

This post may include affiliate links and I may earn commission if you make a purchase through these links. On this episode of Play. Learn. Thrive., clinical psychologist Sarah Mundy shares with Alanna insights about the importance of play in the development of confident, self-motivated, independent kids. In addition to being a core element of…

Risky Play: What Parents NEED to Know

Risky Play This post may include affiliate links and I may earn commission if you make a purchase through these links. Children have an innate need for risk-taking. In addition, children who are encouraged to take risks at a younger age are able to better manage risk once they have gained more independence. A lack…